Sunday, September 16, 2012

Putting Respect in Perspective - Aaron Crouse


The 1999 FIFA Women’s World Cup held in the United States marked the beginning of a new era for women’s soccer.  The tournament was expanded to 16 teams, games were held in massive NFL stadiums, and media coverage was significantly increased.  As illustrated through the video in class, many critics believed that the U.S Women’s Soccer team would end up embarrassing themselves by playing in front of empty stadiums as crowds would not be interested in a women’s sport.  These critics ended up being dead wrong.  The American women would end up taking home gold by defeating China in penalty kicks in front of a sellout crowd of 90,125 at the Rose Bowl, marking a newfound victory for not just women’s soccer, but women’s sports overall in the United States (FIFA, 1999, paragraph 3). In an age where is it extremely difficult to meet, yet alone form a relationship with a professional athlete, the 1999 USA Women’s National Soccer team stands out as a team that really did right by their fans in my opinion, leading to the ultimate success of the FIFA World Cup.



One of the major differences that made this team stand out from others was their willingness to engage in grassroots marketing with their fans.  I doubt that any NFL, MLB, or NBA teams would be willing to hold open session camps (for free) and give each youth athlete the attention and time that these U.S. women’s players did.  For anyone who has ever attempted to obtain something as simple as an autograph or handshake at an NFL training camp or before an MLB game, I think you can agree when I say that there is a disconnect (for the most part) between today’s athletes and their fans.  I was very impressed with the way this team presented itself to the public.  Becoming so personal with the youth athletes that came out to see them at the camps not only helped with ticket sales, but also helped in encouraging participation in youth soccer for girls.  The current success of the U.S National Women’s Soccer program along with the popularity of girl’s soccer in middle and high school can be greatly attributed to this team.  Based upon this video and coverage from the Olympics, I would say (that in general) female athletes are much more likely to be appreciative and warm up to their fans than males.  While I cannot prove that this is completely based upon gender differences (or possibly differences in salary), I was very impressed with the way in which the U.S. women genuinely appreciated the individuals who came out to support them.  While fans often defer to male sports for role models and idols, I personally wish more of our male athletes approached interviews and their supporters in the way females do.  In having to “earn” their fans with more difficulty, female athletes have a better understanding the time and effort that goes in to supporting a team and a player.  Not only are many of these women great athletes, but we are also able to find out who they are as people.  You can only learn so much about a person from what you see on television, read on twitter, or get out of a 30-second interview.  Many current male athletes should take a lesson from the 1999 USA Women’s National soccer team and really get out to meet their fans.  These individuals spend their time and money to come out and watch you play a game, the least you can do is sign an autograph or give a kid a high-five.  It may be insignificant to the athlete, but it is something that the fan or child will remember for the rest of their life.  When in doubt, defer to the actions of the 1999 women because they did it right in my opinion.

9 comments:

  1. I couldn't agree with you more. Athletes, I believe, should always take time a minute to get to know their fans. Without the fans, where would they be? So, why can't they take a few minutes out of their days to interact with the fans that make it possible for them to participate in the sport that they love. Understandingly, athletes are busy people, but they always have a minute or two before or after their competitions. When young growing athletes are able to interact in person with an athlete, it only pushes them to want to be better in that sport and be more like that athlete that they look up to so much. Like you said, it may seem insignificant to the athlete, but it means the world to the children for them to be able to interact with someone that they idolize so much. The fans deserve much more attention from athletes then they actually get. After all, they are part of the ones that make it possible. I believe the NBA, NFL, MLB and NHL teams should do as the women's soccer team did. I believe the teams that reach out to their fans like they did, will have more success than those that don't.

    -Paxin Stern

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was completely clueless as to how much adversity was faced for this U.S. Women's Soccer team until I saw the video in class. This women's team took other people's negative comments and turned it into motivation for them to succeed. They were determined to fill every seat with fans wherever they played and to prove everyone that doubted them wrong. Aaron, you bring up a good point that athletes these days I feel have lost touch with. The 1999 U.S. Women’s National soccer team went above and beyond to just connect with fans which I believe led them to be so successful. I know when I go to MLB games, it is nearly impossible to just get a wave from some players back when fans are screaming there name. This team went out there way to connect with fans on a personal level by signing autographs, having meet and greets, teaching young athletes the skills necessary to play at their best, you name it this team made it happen for their fans. If a team nowadays did what they did would have an amazing fan base, fans of ALL ages would be lining up for these athletes because of the respect and passion they have for their fans. In 1999, they did not have the technology our generation relies on today. A tweet to fans of appreciation is less more sincere than a personal thank you in some form to fans. Do you think if the 1999 team had a Facebook or Twitter would they utilize that instead of making the personal connections like they did? Aaron, a great point you make is the treatment of fans from the two genders. Typically from what I have seen and from my personal experience is female athletes are always willing to take that extra step to give a fan the ultimate experience compared to a male athlete. I feel pay does have something to do with this unfortunately and a bigger head is correlated with the amount of dollar figures an athlete is getting paid. Also, I feel like women are more empathetic to there fans and appreciative since women’s have to work harder to be noticed in the sports world, so they will give back to the one’s who support them along the way.

    -Chelsea VanAssche

    ReplyDelete
  3. I disagree in a sense with the fact that the NFL, NBA and MLB do not need to hold open camps because they are leagues that fans want to watch. The US women’s soccer team needed to connect to the grassroots to grow interest in their sport, which I believe has helped them in the past and present. If the women’s team did not promote their sport, I feel they wouldn’t have got the attendance and support during the World Cup because people wouldn’t have known. The other leagues do not have to do this because younger generations want to grow up and play in the pros. Those leagues get all the marketing and promotion they need without having to go the extra mile to please the fans.

    I do however agree that male athletes should approach fans and interviews in the manner that female athletes do, in which they become more personable and the fans get to feel like they know their role models. As a lifelong sports fan, when I was a child watching interviews, my favorite athletes were the ones that were passionate and humble. When I went to hockey games with my dad I always that it was special when an athlete would interact with a fan, such as giving them a puck during warm-up or an autograph going off the ice. When athletes go out of their way to interact with a fan especially a child, it goes a long way and a memory that last a lifetime

    Ryan Viselli

    ReplyDelete
  4. I completely agree with the fact that women are more appreciative of their fans. This being because male sports get a lot more coverage than female sports. I would also think that they like the feeling of satisfaction. Knowing that they went out there and recruited those fans basically to come to their game, and it worked. Male athletes don't really interact with their fans, unless its an autograph signing like you said. Even then it is so hard to get up close, and actually talk with your favorite players. One of the reasons I am not a big fan of the NFL is because I believe these players don't care about anything besides their money. If they showed a little dedication to their fans like the soccer team did, I would probably get into it a little bit more.

    -Patrick McFall

    ReplyDelete
  5. Aaron,

    I find the points you have brought up interesting. First, I really wanted to explore the difference between how female and male athletes interact with fans. First, let's look at the Bowling Green Volleyball team. After every home game, they do an awesome thing. They line up side by side at the top of the stairs in the Stroh Center. This is called "Meet the Falcons." I have done numerous volleyball broadcasts and it is so fun to watch the kids get excited to meet these competitors that they just watched play on such a big stage. This is a really effective method of relating with the fans and ensuring that they remain interested in the sport and team.

    To compare this to Bowling Green Men's athletics. The hockey team is the only team I have really seen do anything similar to what Volleyball does. Someone could probably prove me wrong because quite a few of you actually play on men's teams here at BG. The hockey team does Skate with the Falcons. Kids can come in and interact with the players on the hockey team. It is fun to watch the kids interact and get excited to watch their local hockey heroes.

    I think there is an obvious disconnect between male athletes and their fans as opposed to female athletes.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Just as a specific example and response to the point about it be extremely difficult to get a professional athletes autograph, I can say that one team does do a good job of this with their athletes. The Cleveland Browns, during training camp in August, allows for close to an hour for players to stay and interact with fans and sign autographs. This sounds typical, but big name players on the team often are the most involved at these sessions and make it seem like they truly care about fan interaction. I do agree that most sports teams and players need improvement in this area, but I wanted to point out one team in my own experiences that I have really been able to enjoy the benefits of the players being open to the public.

    - Joey Durant

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with you Aaron, I do think that athletes today should take the time and sign autographs and give kids high fives. In todays sports there is really only one athelete that i know that actually takes the time to engage his fans and that is Phil Mickelson. But yes i do believe that women are more engaging in there fans than males because of all the television coverage that the males get over the females. Teams and players today need to improve in this area because just like the soccer team they could get younger children involved in the sport that the player or teams are involved in.

    - Tyler Clifton

    ReplyDelete
  8. The point I agree with you most is when you discuss how you doubt that any NFL or NBA teams would hold camps for free for young athletes and take the time that the Unites States Women’s National Team did in terms of autographs and acknowledging their fans. In the video we watched in class one of the players talked about how it didn't matter if they had to stand in the pouring rain that they were going to make sure every youth athlete received and autograph. I would never be able to picture many teams partake in this activity. The women athletes on that team were very generous and sincere for their cause. They are dedicated athletes to not only their team, but society as a whole. They were not only promoting their team for viewing purposes, but promoting the sport as well and helping young athletes excel and strive to be better athletes and fulfill their dreams. The team not only did the impossible on the field, but off as well in multiple ways. I feel as if other teams need to model the USWNT and their actions.

    -Casey Daulbaugh

    ReplyDelete